How We Communicate on Flooding - Social Media Connections - RIP Evidence Based Policy

Evidence-based policies require strong communication to support education and data sharing to build a better understanding of issues. Here are some connections between government agencies and insurance industry players who have a role in flood management :
Can you find Environment Canada in the twitter network above to find out who is following whom? Unfortunately Environment Canada (@environmentca), the federal agency that collects and analyzes extreme rainfall data that shows storm intensities are not increasing, is not prominent in communications.  They do not effectively communicate rain data trends like this:
Real data from Engineering Climate Data Set, Version 2.3.

Who is more prominent in terms of communication on flooding? The Ontario Ministry of the Environment and Climate Change is (@environmentont), but unfortunately they only provide the following infographics on weather and climate, which is not helpful in any way to understanding flood issues:

Connecting the dots on climate change infographics. Non data.  Nonsense.

The insurance industry is prominent in terms of communication on flooding and rainfall extremes, for example @insurancebureau, @iclrcanada, @avivacanada, or @the_cooperators. Unfortunately, Insurance Bureau of Canada's publications through the Institute for Catastrophic Loss Reduction substitute theoretical speculation on climate for actual data on historical extreme weather:

Mathematical conjecture, statistical smoke and mirrors are used by IBC to explain weather phemonena.  In this case, a theoretical one standard deviation shift in a bell curve is used as the basis for explaining Environment Canada rainfall trends.

 A full review of the insurance industry's promotion of incorrect data is in our previous post.

Unfortunately, in this age of Twitter, 140 characters are not enough to explain science, facts, evidence, details, engineering principles, analysis, etc. in any meaningful way and so society is often left uninformed and misled.

Evidence-based policies that must be built on substance and not infographics and mathematical conjecture.

The Ontario Government's is off track and has somehow linked flood damages to climate change, when in fact Environment Canada data shows no increase in storm intensities.

In a CBC report the Minister of the Environment and Climate Change says "Governments, too, are also getting hit. Murray said severe weather events have cost the government hundreds of millions."

Yes damages are increasing but storm frequency is not, so why mention weather events in the roll out of the government's climate change policy at all?  Flood damages are not caused by temperatures increases due to climate change. And extreme weather is different than long term climate.  Dear Minister, will you not respond to my letter?

Oh well, this post is longer than 140 characters so I have lost many of you by now and you have been distracted by some Google ad for drones .. no, wait, that was me.

RIP evidence-based policy in Ontario.


1 comment:

  1. The most ideal approach to remain on target blogis to build up objectives that everybody can concur on before plan and advancement start. Distinguish most blog extreme or normal page size qualities for your site just as greatest download times on regular wired/Wi-Fi and cell associations. You may ask what those maximums ought to be, yet there's not a one-size-fits-all answer. It truly relies blogupon the business and goal blogof the site. For instance, a site for a historical center will have distinctive execution focuses than a value-based internet business website. One of the best methods for guaranteeing blogthat a site is both blog connecting with and performing great is close coordinated effort among blogplanners and engineers. That has gotten simpler as of late with a move to increasingly dexterous improvement draws near. In any case, the key here is for creators and engineers to cooperate during the plan procedure to blogguarantee that the segments and associations being planned don't detrimentally affect execution. This venture stage is truly where you find some kind of harmony between drawing blogin structure and site execution, tending to questions like "is that slider with complex liveliness extremely worth the exhibition sway, or would we be able to accomplish the client experience blogobjective another way?"


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.