Low Impact Development Capital Costs - City of Philadelphia 2018 Annual Report Compiles Green Infrastructure Costs and Service Area

See September 2019 Update and Comparison at Bottom of this Post.

Green Infrastructure (GI), Low Impact Development (LID) Stormwater Best Management Practice (BMP) measures are widely promoted to achieve water management goals including baseflow management (i.e, through groundwater infiltration / recharge) and erosion stress reduction (i.e., through runoff volume reduction for small storms).

The capital cost of GI / LID / BMPs is of considerable interest to those considering implementation on a system-wide basis. In general, the capital cost can be related to the size of the measure, often dictated by the size drainage area it serves.

The City of Philadelphia has been implementing GI / LID / BMP retrofits for many years and has compiled the cost of measures. These have been recently reported in this document (see pdf page 151). This is an excerpt:


Data in the table has been compiled to support cost benefit analysis for flood resiliency assessments. The chart below shows how costs increase as a function of drainage area size.


The slope of the cost vs. drainage area trend line is $295,000 per acre, or $728,000 per hectare considering 85 projects, some with multiple sub-projects.

The 2018 report includes projects completed between 2006 and 2018. When capital costs are adjusted for changes in construction costs, costs can be expressed in 2018 dollars. An adjustment in Philadelphia project costs was based on data from RSMeans (link). The following chart shows green infrastructure capital costs in 2018 dollars vs. drainage area.

 The average cost per acre is $320,000 while the cost per hectare is $792,000. There is a very strong correlation of cost with drainage area serviced by the green infrastructure feature. Weighted by the overall program cost of $56.8M and total drainage area of 164 acres (66 hectares), the program costs per acre and hectare $347,000 and $857,000 respectively. In a previous post the budgeting considered by Philadelphia was $350,000 per impervious acre, or $865,000 per impervious hectare. These costs suggest a lower cost per impervious area than those budget amounts.

The cost of providing storage is indicated in the chart below. Again the overall project or bundled project cost is highly correlated to the storage volume provided by the green infrastructure measures. The average cost is $52.7 per cubic foot or $1850 per cubic metre of storage. Note that the weighted overall program cost is different - the $56.8M cost for 907,000 cubic feet, or 25,700 cubic metres, of storage works out to unit costs of $62.6/cu.ft, or $2200/cu.m
It is worthwhile noting the average storage depth across the drainage areas serviced by the green infrastructure features. The average depth is 25,700 cu.m / 66 hectares = 25,700 / 660,000 = 39 mm. This reflects the range in design of 1 to 2 inches (25-50 mm) intended for CSO control. It is above the depth that is typically used for achieving watershed or catchment water management goals, e.g., water balance management for erosion mitigation, groundwater recharge, or non-point source water quality management. The draft Ministry of Environment, Conservation and Parks Low Impact Development guidance manual proposed control volumes up to 32 mm in Ontario, or 18% below the average depth in the Philadelphia projects.

Unit costs can be used to support high level green infrastructure program and project budgeting. There is scatter within the charts for a given drainage area or storage volume, meaning the cost of an individual project should allow for a high contingency above the average unit costs, until design details are available.

Unit costs can be assessed for various LID types - cost per drainage area for permeable pavement, rain garden, infiltration trench and tree trench projects are shown in the chart below with infiltration trenches having the lowest cost per acre and permeable pavement having the highest. The unit costs of rain gardens and tree trenches are above those of infiltration trenches.



Cost per storage volume for permeable pavement, rain garden, infiltration trench and tree trench projects are shown in the chart below. Again, infiltration trenches having the lowest cost per cubic foot of storage and permeable pavement having the highest cost per storage unit. The unit costs of rain gardens and tree trenches are above those of infiltration trenches.



The inset text boxes on the charts illustrate unit costs (i.e., the slopes of the trend lines):

Unit Cost per Drainage Area Summary:
Infiltration Trench: $260k/acre ($642k/hectare)
Pervious Pavement: $594k/acre ($1.47M/hectare)
Rain Garden: $408k/acre ($1.01M/hectare)
Tree Trench: $318k/acre ($790k/hectare)

Unit Cost per Storage Volume Summary:
Infiltration Trench: $49.0/cf ($1730/cu.m)
Pervious Pavement: $97.2/cf ($3430/cu.m)
Rain Garden: $60.1/cf ($2120/cu.m)
Tree Trench: $58.9/cf ($2080/cu.m)

***

Green Infrastructure Strategies?

In Ontario, there are approximately 852,000 urban hectares that have no green infrastructure controls  in the year 2000 (per SOLRIS GIS land use data). Implementing green infrastructure across all these areas, similar to Philadelphia, would cost 853,000 x $857,000 = $730 billion - this is 100 times greater than the entire Ontario stormwater infrastructure deficit, and a similar magnitude to Ontario's annual GDP ($854B in 2018). Philadelphia is targeting a specific need for CSO control to justify its green infrastructure investment. Given this magnitude of cost, to make green infrastructure affordable in Ontario certainly requires a strategic assessment on where it is implemented. The expected annual flood damage loss in Ontario is $292M, meaning that if flood control green infrastructure reduces the cost by half each year for 50 years (assumed service life), the total savings is $7.3B - why would one invest 100 times that loss ($730B) in green infrastructure?

Ontario's Draft LID (Low Impact Development) Manual sets a generic goal of implementing LID / green infrastructure in new development and retrofit development (including linear infrastructure). Cost concerns with a generic approach have been identified by the Ontario Society of Professional Engineers in comments on Bill 139 assuming unit cost of $400,000 per hectare based on a small set of Ontario tender costs. Those costs were for small volume installations, whereas the Philadelphia program costs are for high volume installations.

***

Update September 2019

The following is a comparison of costs from three sources:
i) Philadelphia (costs above),
ii) Ontario and Alberta project review (expanding previous list), and NEW
iii) EPA International BMP Database costs review.

Green Infrastructure Costs - Philadelphia, Ontario, Alberta and US EPA BMP Database Projects
Costs are normalized by drainage area and grouped by type of LID BMP.  An important design parameter is shown in the second last row - i.e., storage volume - that helps explain the variability in some program costs.  For example, Philadelphia storage volumes average 38.9 mm across the catchment being served while the EPA database projects average 6.6 mm - Philadelphia is pursuing CSO control with target storage volumes of 1-2 inches.  Other EPA BMP Database projects incorporate much smaller storage volumes on average.  Note that Philadelphia has a high cost per hectare but this is due to a higher design volume - their cost/hectare is 4.1 times the EPA project cost, but the design volume is 5.9 times greater.  This shows a higher cost efficiency in Philadelphia for the larger projects.  This is seen in the cost per ha-mm or cost per cubic metre of storage (only $22,000 / ha-mm for Philadelphia vs. $32,000 per ha-mm for EPA projects).

Some more notes:
- the Ontario costs in bold are for entire projects what may include several components, which is why the individual LID type costs are lower
- Ontario data omits storage for most projects, which is a gap that should be filled in the future
- the costs per storage volume in EPA for permeable pavement and infiltration trenches seem low, based on large storage projects that suggest costs of $400-500 / cu.m for large centralized facilities

How can the unit costs for LIDs be applied, say in planning level studies?  Well ...

In Ontario, 5 mm is a general criterion for erosion control (Toronto and Region Conservation Authority watershed) and is the control volume for Toronto's Wet Weather Flow Management Program.  The compiled costs can be used to show that providing this 5 mm of storage would cost $160,000 per  hectare ($32,000/ha-mm x 5 mm).

In a typical storm sewer catchment with a 50 hectare drainage area the capital cost would be $8M to implement 5 mm LID storage across the catchment/drainage area.

Across Ontario, with 852,000 hectares of urban development built before 2000, the cost to implement 5 mm of LID storage would be $136B, or about 20 times Ontario's current stormwater infrastructure deficit.

20 comments:

  1. On the off chance that property estimations have fallen fundamentally Very nice in your locale, ensure that your duty evaluation esteem is reasonable. In the event that it's not reasonable, apply for a re-appraisal. In people group where property I didn’t know this estimations have fallen generously, this can spare you a great deal of cash in property charges.
    In the event that you are independently employed, Informative do you do your own duties or do you have an expert bookkeeper with an expert assignment like CA, CGA or CMA do your charges for you? On the off chance that your duties aren't being well written finished by one of these experts, you could be passing up some enormous duty reserve funds. On the off chance that you feel that these sorts of bookkeepers are costly, that might be valid, however it is regularly Read increasingly costly to pay the administration a large number of dollars in pointless expenses than to pay a decent bookkeeper a couple hundred dollars to discover these reserve read funds for you. On the off chance that you are extremely frugal, you can evaluate the bookkeeper once to check whether you are feeling the loss of any findings, and afterward you can return to your old method for doing charges and utilize the duty sparing tips that you gained from the bookkeeper.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Extremely intriguing online journal. A lot of web journals I see nowadays don't generally give anything that I'm keen on, however I'm most definitely inspired by this one. Recently felt that I would post and let you know.
    Modular drainage system

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nice post! This is a very nice blog that I will definitively come back to more times this year! Thanks for informative post. dewalt cordless impact wrench review

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have been using this tool for a long time now. This is a nice post aout Milwuakee 2767. I have got more and more from another blog click here

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have been using this tool for a long time now. This is a nice post aout Milwuakee 2767. I have got more and more from another blog click herelow water trees for California

    ReplyDelete
  6. Great idea man thanks keep it up all the time. i am very happy to see your standard. Really I appreciate you to continue your work. if you want to get one of the best Hydrology assignments help experts online. then visit our website.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Natural Herbal Medicine To Cure {HERPES DISEASE} TOTALLY HERE
    Do you need a solution to cure your Herpes Disease contact Chief Dr Lucky to help and he will surely help you to cure your Herpes Virus .. I have suffered from Herpes-2 Virus for 4years ago that almost took my life. But one day I was searching the internet and I found Chief Dr Lucky saw so many testimonies on how Chief Dr Lucky helps people in curing their deadly diseases, and I contacted Chief Dr Lucky, asked him for solutions and he started the remedies for my health. He prepared herbal medicine for me and I received the herbal medicine and after using it for 2 weeks my condition has greatly improved, all my symptoms including Abdominal pain, Nausea and vomiting, Loss of appetite stopped, so I went to my doc and was confirmed negative. I am Herpes Virus free! contact the herbal doctor via his email> chiefdrlucky@gmail.com also visit his page> http://facebook.com/chiefdrlucky or his cell number / WhatsApp> +2348132777335 Website > http://chiefdrlucky.com

    ReplyDelete
  8. A very Wonderful blog. We believe that you have a busy, active lifestyle and also understand you need marijuana products from time to time. We’re ICO sponsored and in collaboration with doctors, deliveries, storefronts and deals worldwide, we offer a delivery service – rated 안전놀이터

    ReplyDelete
  9. Excellent information on your blog, thank you for taking the time to share with us. Amazing insight you have on this, it's nice to find a website that details so much information about different artists Wow, wonderful blog layout! How long have you ever been blogging for? you made running a blog glance easy. The full look of your website is great, let alone the content! Very good points you wrote here..Great stuff...I think you've made some truly interesting points.Keep up the good work 메이저놀이터

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hi! I’m at work browsing your blog from my new iphone 4! Just wanted to say I love reading your blog and look forward to all your posts! Carry on the superb work!I’m not sure exactly why but this weblog is loading incredibly slow for me. Is anyone else having this issue or is it a issue on my end? I’ll check back later on and see if the problem still exists. 토토사이트

    ReplyDelete
  11. Through this post, I know that your good knowledge in playing with all the pieces was very helpful. I notify that this is the first place where I find issues I've been searching for. You have a clever yet attractive way of writing. I am always searching online for articles that can help me. There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think you made some good points in Features also. Keep working, great job It is perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I've read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you some interesting things or suggestions. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. I want to read more things about it! 먹튀폴리스

    ReplyDelete
  12. I just like the valuable info you provide on your articles. I’ll bookmark your weblog and take a look at once more right here regularly. I’m moderately sure I’ll learn many new stuff right here! Good luck for the following!I am sure this paragraph has touched all the internet users, its really really nice article on building up new website.| 먹튀검증

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thank you again for all the knowledge you distribute,Good post. I was very interested in the article, it's quite inspiring I should admit. I like visiting you site since I always come across interesting articles like this one.Great Job, I greatly appreciate that.Do Keep sharing! Regards Attractive component of content. I just stumbled upon your site and in accession capital to claim that I acquire actually enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I will be subscribing for your feeds or even I success you access consistently quickly. 토토하이

    ReplyDelete
  14. Excellent post. I was always checking this blog, and I’m impressed! Extremely useful info specially the last part, I care for such information a lot. I was exploring this particular info for a long time. Thanks to this blog my exploration has ended. Fabulous post, you have denoted out some fantastic points, I likewise think this s a very wonderful website. I will visit again for more quality contents and also, recommend this site to all. Thanks. 먹튀프렌즈

    ReplyDelete
  15. If you are going for most excellent contents like myself, just pay a visit this site all the time for the reason that it presents feature contents, thanks..Thank you, I’ve just been looking for information about this subject for ages and yours is the greatest I’ve discovered till now. But, what about the bottom line? Are you sure about the source? 카디즈에이전시

    ReplyDelete
  16. Howdy! I could have sworn I’ve been to this blog before but after reading through some of the post I realized it’s new to me. Nonetheless, I’m definitely happy I found it and I’ll be bookmarking and checking back frequently! 안전사이트

    ReplyDelete
  17. We’re a group of volunteers and starting a brand new scheme in our community. Your web site provided us with helpful information to work on. You’ve performed an impressive process and our entire community will likely be grateful to you.| 먹튀검증백과

    ReplyDelete
  18. "I just found this blog and have high hopes for it to continue. Keep up the great work, its hard to find good ones. I have added to my favorites. Thank You. I really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to understand. Unlike other blogs I have read which are really not that good.Thanks alot!
    I am really enjoying reading your well written articles. It looks like you spend a lot of effort and time on your blog. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work." 토토디펜드

    ReplyDelete
  19. Useful information. Lucky me I found your website accidentally, and I am stunned why this accident didn’t came about in advance! I bookmarked it., it seems good. I’ve bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.Hi there, I discovered your web site by the use of Google even as looking for a similar subject, your site got here up, 안전놀이터

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.